“What’s the methodology behind this number?”
“We only need 1% of the market” scores 0 on the method test. A bottom-up model with its assumptions stated scores 2. If you cannot explain how a number was derived, the sheet will show it.
This free claims self-audit is a scoring sheet for your sales deck, website, proposal or board pack. Score each claim 0, 1 or 2 on six tests in about fifteen minutes. Anything below 8 out of 12 needs fixing.
Free PDF · no spam
Instant download, plus a copy by email. Includes Friday Notes; unsubscribe in one click.
Your download has started. Didn’t see it?
Download the PDF AgainReady for a verified score on the real thing? Get a First Signal →
Built on the evidence standard behind Release Assurance
What it asks
Each one maps to a test in the sheet. They are the same standard Release Assurance uses, where a named verifier checks every claim before it goes out.
“What’s the methodology behind this number?”
“We only need 1% of the market” scores 0 on the method test. A bottom-up model with its assumptions stated scores 2. If you cannot explain how a number was derived, the sheet will show it.
“What sample size is this based on?”
A satisfaction score with no sample size scores 0. “n=12, first cohort” scores 2. Being honest about the sample earns the score, whatever its size.
“Does this survive the regulator, not just the objection you expected?”
The challenge runs three hostile readings (the sceptical buyer, the regulator and the plain explanation), and a claim has to survive all three. The regulator’s reading is hardest in financial services, health and other regulated sectors.
The self-audit walks through the five citation criteria, the three-position challenge, a scoring sheet and a wider four-angle check of the whole document. Get the Free PDF
What’s inside
Five citation criteria and one challenge, each scored 0, 1 or 2 per claim. Twelve is the maximum. Below eight, the claim is a risk.
Could someone else find the exact source?
An “as of” date and a re-check on time-sensitive figures.
How the number was worked out, as well as the number.
The n behind the figure, as well as the headline.
High, medium or low, with no false precision.
The sceptical buyer, the regulator and the plain explanation.
In one sitting
Three to five claims the document cannot survive without: the market number, the headline result, the differentiator.
Run every claim through the five criteria and the three-position challenge, 0, 1 or 2 per test. Be as hard as a regulator would be.
A claim below 8 of 12 is a risk. Source it, date it, show the method, state the n, or cut it.
Go deeper
The self-audit shows where your claims are likely to fall short. An independent check goes further. A free First Signal reads your deck or page and flags the claims a careful buyer would doubt. When it has to be right before it goes out, Release Assurance checks every claim and a named verifier signs the result.